Comments on: BuzzFeed’s search for marginalized writers is progressive, not racist http://rrj.ca/buzzfeeds-search-for-marginalized-writers-is-progressive-not-racist/ Canada's Watchdog on the watchdogs Sun, 15 May 2016 11:59:14 +0000 hourly 1 By: Ike http://rrj.ca/buzzfeeds-search-for-marginalized-writers-is-progressive-not-racist/#comment-577932 Thu, 25 Feb 2016 23:23:40 +0000 http://rrj.ca/?p=8024#comment-577932 As a black male, I stand against buzzfeed on this. They’re literally doing something that if one word of the people said to “need not apply” was different everyone including this writer who is against the out cry thst has happened, would be tearing that person apart. Dr. King was for anyone regardless of skin color based solely on merit, he died for that, stuff like this hiring practice are against that on a fundamental level. Also the fact they had to exclude white men makes me think : A. Buzzfeed knows white men would be just as qualified or More qualified so they must fudge the deck in order to see the people they want on this (discrimation) or B. They think white men are an issue within journalism (discrimination).

If you don’t believe me switch those words with any other sexual and/or racial identifier and think how wrong it’d be if someone said :white Trans need not apply, black women need not apply, Arabic nonidentifying need not apply. It feels disgusting, so why do that to anyone even if “historically they’ve been advantaged”. Because last time I checked historical advantage didn’t play apart in the life son of a Russian immigrant family, who made it past the Iron curtain under threat of death to America, pursuing journalism just to be rejected by a place due to having light skin and identifying as male.

]]>
By: Connie http://rrj.ca/buzzfeeds-search-for-marginalized-writers-is-progressive-not-racist/#comment-567475 Mon, 22 Feb 2016 18:55:29 +0000 http://rrj.ca/?p=8024#comment-567475 Is that what her hateful vitriol is called nowadays… “progressive” ?
Her constant snark, negativity and divisive language doesn’t promote anything except more of that.
This woman needs to seriously grow up and assess her own contributions to the toxic sludge online before crying foul.

]]>
By: Will George http://rrj.ca/buzzfeeds-search-for-marginalized-writers-is-progressive-not-racist/#comment-565692 Mon, 22 Feb 2016 05:16:02 +0000 http://rrj.ca/?p=8024#comment-565692 Scaachi is lying when she says she was only trying to bring diversity into her newsroom. If that was really the case, she could have simply wrote, “Please pitch me ideas. I’d especially like to hear from women, people of color, trans, and indiginous.” Instead, she sent out a series of hostile tweets that show she harbors a deep hatred for white men. The angry Twitter feminist is so cliche anymore.

]]>
By: Vanitas http://rrj.ca/buzzfeeds-search-for-marginalized-writers-is-progressive-not-racist/#comment-565542 Mon, 22 Feb 2016 04:12:45 +0000 http://rrj.ca/?p=8024#comment-565542 Why do only White countries need to be “diversified”? Would you complain about the lack of Whites on Japanese or Nigerian television?

]]>
By: Hector http://rrj.ca/buzzfeeds-search-for-marginalized-writers-is-progressive-not-racist/#comment-565059 Mon, 22 Feb 2016 00:54:19 +0000 http://rrj.ca/?p=8024#comment-565059 “@Scott_Gilmore @Scaachi it’s clearly not a job ad, and it violates no laws to encourage women & poc to pitch. But yeah thx for the link.
— Craig Silverman (@CraigSilverman) February 20, 2016

This is the boss of Buzzfeed whom despite their reputation is a very large and known website defending her terrible behaviour on loopholes. What a joke!!!

]]>
By: Hector http://rrj.ca/buzzfeeds-search-for-marginalized-writers-is-progressive-not-racist/#comment-565044 Mon, 22 Feb 2016 00:48:04 +0000 http://rrj.ca/?p=8024#comment-565044 This story like the Huffington Post is telling what it wants its narrative to be. You’re leaving out her baiting, vile posts that she posted were written to get a reaction out of people. That her editor is trying to play this off as semantics is insulting, disrespectful and just as unprofessional. No one has a problem with her seeking out diverse voices, it’s how she presented herself after the first post.

This isn’t progressive, this is letting a woman with too much power and too little maturity rule the coup no matter the decisions. If you have to defend something from being not illegal but still pretty unethical and only tell what you want, then you’re no better. What a shameful way of exploiting this and making it seem this is a random hit piece on her. She conducted herself so poorly and while racist and equally venomous comments towards her took it too far, her conduct absolutely should be questioned. She’s her own worst enemy and this backfired. Lost among the obnoxious remarks between her and her posters are legitimate questions about her professionalism and the double standard of their future hiring prospects. Don’t tell me it’s a non-issue because you technically weren’t hiring or didn’t specifically word it one way or the other. This is an issue you can’t back peddle and squirm your way out of, which is being exhibited here. Instead of an apology or stand by either side, it automatically becomes a poor Scaahi story. Embarrassing for her, Buzzfeed and her followers. You can’t have it both ways, just own up to your mistakes and be done with it.

Plan B is taking time off Twitter to build up her sympathy and come back with a HiringGate type angle for her book. But Plan A was so poorly executed that the basis for her getting the attention she thought she was going to get isn’t there though and explaining her nasty attitude for reaction isn’t something to boast about.

]]>
By: Kelv http://rrj.ca/buzzfeeds-search-for-marginalized-writers-is-progressive-not-racist/#comment-565014 Mon, 22 Feb 2016 00:34:25 +0000 http://rrj.ca/?p=8024#comment-565014 People don’t seem to understand what racism is. Being a person of an ethnic minority myself, I would not want the next generation to assume that racism towards white people or sexism is okay. Yes she is fighting for diversity and wants to hire writers from different background, but there is no need to blatantly state this because you have convinced yourself that your views is correct and is progressive and what is worse you are trying to normalise that this sort of message on twitter is acceptable. All her artricles regarding Men and White people have been condescending and its going on for far too long. This sort of open racism is far more damaging than people realise. I’m not about to let my kids be taught that racism towards white people is okay, and why are we perpetuating this sort of behavior? Shame to all the other journalist who backs this and shame too all the ethnic minority who think this is okay. If you are an ethnic minority and you have become racist or sexist – check your bloody privilege. Stop the racism now – regardless if its towards Black, White, Arab, Asian. If you won’t write “No Black Male” and deem it offensive, dont write “No White Male” its not hard – are u guys stupid? Koul been brainwashed and people need to stop supporting this sort of views before another generation of racial hate continues and the entire civil rights movement will all be for nothing.

]]>
By: Dylan http://rrj.ca/buzzfeeds-search-for-marginalized-writers-is-progressive-not-racist/#comment-564647 Sun, 21 Feb 2016 21:58:47 +0000 http://rrj.ca/?p=8024#comment-564647 When you said Koul “was forced off social media” did you mean she chose to leave to avoid to the harassment? Or did her company ask her to leave? It reads like the latter.

]]>
By: James http://rrj.ca/buzzfeeds-search-for-marginalized-writers-is-progressive-not-racist/#comment-564359 Sun, 21 Feb 2016 19:55:39 +0000 http://rrj.ca/?p=8024#comment-564359 Totally missing the mark on this, and selectively reporting no less.

Scaachi wasn’t harassed off Twitter for reaching out to POC, which would have been a commendable act. She specifically, verbatim told white men their contributions wouldn’t be valued. Had she left out the misandrist, racist snark, this would have been a non-story. Unfortunately, this is consistent throughout her material.

How this somehow translates into progressive thought is beyond my reach. Inclusivity doesn’t have to be at the explicit expense of any one group. Imagine calling for fitness writers by asking for “non-cripples” — it’s totally unnecessary and unbecoming of her employer.

]]>
By: Cameron http://rrj.ca/buzzfeeds-search-for-marginalized-writers-is-progressive-not-racist/#comment-564281 Sun, 21 Feb 2016 19:20:26 +0000 http://rrj.ca/?p=8024#comment-564281 “Clearly harrassment is bad, but gosh she was askingfor it.”…

Hell is fellow white people.

]]>